Garuda Indonesia sues vlogger for posting viral photo of handwritten flight menu

The airline has banned cabin photos and videos.

Jason Fan | July 17, 2019, 06:58 PM

Companies do not usually like it when customers give bad reviews.

Garuda Indonesia apparently does not like it a lot as it has taken things one step further after a vlogger posted a photo of the plane's handwritten menu on his Instagram account.

The airline's response was swift, releasing a circular that banned passengers from taking photos and videos inside the aircraft cabin.

The airline even made a police report against the vlogger and his fiance, accusing them of defamation.

What happened?

Rius Vernandes, a popular Indonesian travel vlogger, posted a photo on his Instagram of a handwritten menu card, which was distributed to business class passengers on his Garuda Indonesia flight from Sydney to Bali.

Instead of just hoping that the matter will blow over, Garuda Indonesia went on the offensive.

Garuda Indonesia responded to the viral photo by stating that the menu card was not for passengers, and it was merely a personal note for flight attendants that should not have been distributed in the first place.

In a statement to Kompas, Garuda Indonesia's corporate secretary vice president M. Ikhsan Rosan refuted the claim that the menu card was distributed to passengers, and stated that it was only for use by the cabin crew.

He also claimed that if the handwritten card was indeed meant for distribution, other passengers should have gotten it as well, and would have shared it.

He also questioned how Rius obtained the handwritten menu and what his intention was in sharing it.

Some commenters online were also suspicious of Rius's intentions, as he had recently participated in marketing campaigns with competitor Singapore Airlines.

Video proof

However, these claims were refuted after Rius posted video proof that he was not the only passenger that was given the handwritten menus.

He also showed proof that he regularly posts photos of his menus during his videos.

In the 21-minute video, Rius gave a comprehensive account of his experience on the flight.


Besides the issue with the handwritten cards, he also mentioned catering issues on board the plane.

When he asked two Australian passengers about their honest opinion about the flight, they noted that although the seats and the food were good, a major problem was that there was a lack of champagne and wine, which ran out quickly after the flight started.

They remarked that although Garuda Indonesia's reputation was improving, the lack of alcohol would make them reconsider taking the airline in the future.

Garuda Indonesia strikes back

Soon after the incident, Garuda Indonesia published an internal memo, prohibiting all forms of photography and videography by passengers and cabin crew.

The memo warned that violating this rule would lead to unspecified sanctions imposed by the airline.

Image from Kumparan.

A few hours after the circular was out, it was revised.

The new circular stated that the rule on taking photos and videos was not a total prohibition, but rather to avoid infringing on the privacy of other passengers and cabin crew.

Image from Kumparan.

Subsequently, Rius posted a photo on his Instagram, showing brown envelopes that supposedly contains police summons.

View this post on Instagram

Guys, gw sama elwi dapat panggilan dari polisi mengenai masalah ini. Kami di laporkan atas dugaan melakukan tindak pidana pencemaran nama baik. Gw yakin kalian tau kalau gw TIDAK ADA maksud sama sekali untuk mencemarkan nama baik siapapun. ⁣ ⁣ Gw sangat minta support kalian soal ini. Semua nya. Siapa pun. Kalian semua punya suara. Terutama teman2 influencer. Gw harap kalian bisa bantu share dan support gw dalam masalah ini karena gw gak mau di masa depan ketika kita review sesuatu dengan apa adanya, ketika kita memberikan kritisi yang membangun, kita bisa di pidana. ⁣ ⁣ Gw akan menghormati segala peraturan hukum yang ada dan akan menjalani semua ini. Gw sama sekali tidak merasa mencemarkan nama baik. Gw tidak takut. Tapi tidak ada kah cara yang lebih kekeluargaan dalam menyelesaikan masalah ini?

A post shared by Rius Vernandes (@rius.vernandes) on

The caption said he and his fiance were reported for defamation, and although he will cooperate with the legal process, he did not think that he defamed Garuda Indonesia, and hoped that constructive criticism will not lead to one being criminalised.

It was later confirmed that Garuda Indonesia did indeed report the couple to the police, for alleged violations of the Electronic Transaction Information Act (ITE).

If convicted, Rius may face up to four years in prison for the dissemination of defamatory content online.

Top image via Rius Vernandes YouTube/Instagram.


Content that keeps going

Do-nothing beach holidays can be stressful for the productivity-obsessed. How uniquely Singaporean.

If you're the type that never leaves home without your phone and wallet, you might wanna try this out.

Click here if you need some tear-jerking wholesomeness