Are the odds in the Bukit Batok by-election stacked for or against Chee Soon Juan?

Let's also hope that the odds are in Bukit Batok residents' favour.

Ng Yi Shu| Jeanette Tan| March 20, 05:48 PM

The opposition Singapore Democratic Party (SDP) is sending secretary-general Chee Soon Juan to stand in the upcoming by-election (BE) in Bukit Batok SMC.

The election, which has to be called "within a reasonable time", and speculated by some to occur in May, was sparked by the resignation of incumbent People’s Action Party (PAP) MP David Ong on March 12.

 

Now, we've given this some thought, and see three key things working for, as well as against, Chee.

Things working for him:

1. His candidacy and campaign continues the redemption arc that Chee was building in the last General Election (GE).

chee-soon-juan-cbd-then

Chee’s candidacy, barring any gaffes, would be a good continuation of the story we saw from GE2015. Since his contest last year — his first in 15 years — he has managed to gain supporters, and his party has started looking significantly more credible than when he was at the helm in the late '90s.

The former academic and neuropsychologist showed us his gentler side, opening up about his family and working harder to identify with voters in his GE2015 campaign approach.

An Institute of Policy Studies (IPS) poll found almost half of Singaporeans felt the SDP was credible last year, a 24 per cent hike from GE2011.

His one main obstacle, however, will be the fact that social media will not do much in swinging votes in his favour, even though his messaging may be on point.

In that same poll, the IPS also found that 47.3 per cent of Singaporean voters had already decided on who to vote for even before election day, and that social media did not have much impact on ballot outcomes.

 

2. The by-election effect, which often helps buoy the opposition candidate.

Swing voters are always willing to at least seriously consider any alternatives to the ruling party during the BE.

This is because the BE is triggered by a mis-step on the part of the incumbent in the first place, which indicates that the initial person they voted in, and by extension the party he or she belonged to, has let residents down.

A reason some touted to explain the massive vote swing toward the PAP in GE2015 was the fact that all wards were contested, triggering a fear of the PAP being toppled in favour of an opposition majority in Parliament. Coordinating Minister for Infrastructure Khaw Boon Wan exploited these honestly unfounded concerns, declaring there was no "safe seat" for the PAP to win.

But as with the previous two BEs in the past four years, the PAP starts at a disadvantage - it will continue to form the government after the Bukit Batok by-election, so voters can cast their ballots for Chee without fear of losing their government.

Thus, Chee stands a real chance if he makes the right moves, does and says the right things.

 

3. His change of tack to take a local tone instead of a national one, by leading with town council management

Photo by Ng Yi Shu Photo by Ng Yi Shu

The SDP has had its alternative town council plan since the last GE — the most recent of its battery of alternatives, from healthcare to the economy — but the fact that it led with the town council plan informs us of its realisation that elections are ultimately very much local.

Chee has promised a host of things he will do with the town council should he take control of it, while according to mainstream media, also plans to hold quarterly town halls and annual elections for town council officers.

But whether the SDP’s idealism rubs off on residents is another issue.

Apart from veteran Chiam See Tong's work in Potong Pasir SMC (1984 to 2011), SDP under Chee's leadership remains untested in the area of town council management.

Besides Workers' Party candidates, only Singapore Democratic Alliance Chairman Desmond Lim had highlighted his extensive experience in Town Council management, having helped Chiam as a consultant at Potong Pasir Town Council for 14 years.

This is a common hurdle all opposition parties vying for parliamentary seats will have to eventually cross.

And here are the things working against him:

1. He may be running against PAP’s Murali Pillai, who has some pretty good grassroots credentials.

47-year old Muraliharan Pillai, a commercial litigation lawyer and former Branch Secretary of PAP Bukit Batok, is fast looking like the top choice for the PAP’s candidate in the Bukit Batok BE.

Murali, according to former Minister Lim Boon Heng, was a "heavyweight" in the PAP Aljunied GRC suicide squad team, and is familiar to Bukit Batok:

Murali_Pillai_CV

Now, 95 per cent of Bukit Batok’s residents live in public housing and 71 per cent stay in one- to four-room flats.

Chee might have the upper hand in relating to residents, since he lives in a three-room flat.

But Bukit Batok is part of the "Jurong GRC family" and a stronghold of PAP.

Backed by the popular Deputy Prime Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam (whose Jurong GRC team was the top scorer at 79.28%), Murali or any PAP candidate familiar with Bukit Batok, will be tough to beat.

 

2. David Ong enjoyed a huge vote share in GE2015.

Screenshot from mothership.sg/ge2015 Screenshot from mothership.sg/ge2015

If GE2015 is anything to go by, it seems Bukit Batok SMC residents are either pretty happy with the PAP or weren't impressed by the opposition.

Throw in the fact that a recent opinion poll by Blackbox Research, which does research on government satisfaction indices in Singapore (yes, those are legal) shows 78.9 per cent of people were satisfied with the government, and you've got a pretty darn uphill climb for Chee ahead.

Singapore's last BE, in 2013, the familiarity of Lee Li Lian aside, came on the back of dissatisfaction with the Population White Paper, the SMRT bus drivers' strike, and several huge train breakdowns.

Even if the SDP claims it garnered 48 per cent of the votes in 1991 when it last contested one-on-one, the situation then was extremely different too.

Back then, the PAP witnessed declining vote share in two consecutive elections prior to 1991.

It was also the first post-LKY-as-PM election, and the SDP was far more popular with Chiam at the helm, and had three MPs elected into parliament.

 

3. Chee needs to explain his seeming absence from grassroots efforts and outreach since the last election.

During the press conference, Chee announced various initiatives to engage Bukit Batok residents, including a quarterly town hall for residents to bring up issues, as well as the town council plan.

Yet, when asked about what he has done on the ground in recent years, Chee said his party was blocked from doing so:

" width="560" height="315" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen="allowfullscreen">

“We have tried so often to come down to the ground, to speak to the residents, but every step of the way, we’re given the answer ’no’.”

He also said this:

href="https://www.facebook.com/MothershipSG/videos/1125790404127277/">Chee Soon Juan on his chances in the Bukit Batok SMC by-electi...Chee Soon Juan attacks the mainstream media in front of the mainstream media. He also explains why he is standing in Bukit Batok when he stood in Holland-Bukit Timah in GE2015:

Posted by Mothership.sg on Saturday, 19 March 2016

The party seems to be seen more as the high-profile campaign than the door-to-door walking-type organisation, as evidenced in Chee's cross-island walkathon last year, for instance:

After'>
4 arduous days of walking around Singapore as part of the #WalkTheTalk2015 fundraising event, Dr Chee arrived at...

Posted by Singapore Democratic Party (SDP) on Monday, 16 November 2015

Being known isn't an issue for Chee, a prominent national political figure.

But it remains to be seen whether he can garner enough support from Bukit Batok residents themselves, and not the liberals across the island or online.

 

We think this can only bode well for Chee and the SDP, though.

The benefits of winning Bukit Batok SMC are obvious, but Chee also stands to gain even if he loses the BE.

The national platform his campaign will give him will ensure that at the very least, he'll get to build influence and credibility — provided he plays his cards right.

By starting in the West side of Singapore, as opposed to the WP-dominated East, the SDP can also invest manpower and effort in building a stronger base there in order to cement itself in the region.

Chee seems to see the situation differently, though — he appeared somewhat visibly exasperated when a reporter asked him what he assessed his chances in Bukit Batok to be.

“We are doing this (running) despite the undemocratic system that we are up against,” Chee said. "We don’t talk about chances; we come down, we work, we persuade, we convince, and try to see if we can overcome the obstacles despite all these barriers that are in front of us.”

Related article:

SDP chief Chee Soon Juan announces he will stand in Bukit Batok SMC by-election

 

Top photo by Ng Yi Shu.

If you like what you read, follow us on Facebook and Twitter to get the latest updates.

If you like what you read, follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and Telegram to get the latest updates.