5 observations of how the PAP will tackle the "Chee by-election" in Bukit Batok

We saw what you did there, DPM Tharman.

Martino Tan| Jeanette Tan| March 22, 11:27 AM

On Monday (March 21), the ruling People's Action Party (PAP) bounced back just a week after suffering their second affair-addled setback in four years to introduce their candidate for the Bukit Batok SMC by-election, lawyer and ex-Aljunied GRC candidate Murali Pillai.

Buffered by heavyweights like Deputy Prime Minister (DPM) Tharman Shanmugaratnam and Minister for Community, Culture and Youth (MCCY) Grace Fu, Murali, who had only on Sunday evening just returned from a holiday, oscillated slightly between calm and slightly unsure of himself — not quite the "titan in the courtroom" his company bio describes him to be. Maybe it is the jet-lag.

We attended his unveiling in the early evening, and here are our takeaways from it:

1. Murali was placed at the centre, but as usual, DPM Tharman took centre stage.

Photo by Lim Weixiang for Mothership.sg Photo by Lim Weixiang for Mothership.sg. Not in the picture is Ang Wei Neng, who is at the far right.

It sounded almost like a repeat of the Jurong and Bukit Batok candidate unveiling in GE2015, which we brazenly titled "The Tharman Show".

We're not sure what it is — his elusiveness to media or his sheer popularity as a minister — but the press is endlessly drawn to him as the person to pose questions to, anytime he's in the room, barring the added presence of Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong himself.

Despite the press conference being about Murali, most of the questions asked were aimed at him, resulting in Tharman speaking even more than the party's candidate.

It was Tharman who opened the press conference, and Tharman who addressed the higher-level strategy questions, including several questioning the timing of the party's announcement of its candidate.

It was also Tharman who tackled the issue of Murali being of minority race despite Bukit Batok having a higher concentration of Chinese residents than the national average head-on.

When asked about it, he said "race is never absent from politics anywhere and we did consider this very carefully", adding that even after Singapore Democratic Party (SDP) Chief Chee Soon Juan's announcement of his candidacy, "we are still very comfortable with Murali as our choice".

Tharman also mentioned a vote for Murali is "a vote for cohesiveness", explaining that coming from a humble background, Murali is a representation of Singapore's multiracialism, and people "see something about Singapore in him that they can associate with very easily".

 

2. DPM Tharman tried to stay away from outrightly criticising the SDP chief, who on Sunday announced his candidacy. But he couldn't resist subtle digs at two points:

Photo by Lim Weixiang for Mothership.sg Photo by Lim Weixiang for Mothership.sg

"I think we've chosen the right person with regard to character, the way people know him and the way people have worked with him in the past. I don't want to make direct comparisons but I think you know what I mean in Murali. One, we feel very comfortable with Murali being up against Dr Chee Soon Juan. We think he is the right person. And we think Bukit Batok residents will appreciate that." (Our emphasis in bold)

And later on, here:

"I'm glad Dr Chee has now recognised the importance of running a town council well — because the last time this came up because before the Punggol East election he had wanted to outsource it to the Workers' Party if you recall — he must have had a change in mind and realises that here in Bukit Batok, it is important to focus on those tasks. It's not the only duty of an MP but we should focus on the task and do it well apart from all the other ways in which we represent our residents." (Our emphasis in bold)

3. Minister Grace Fu spoke only Mandarin at the press conference, signalling she might become Murali's Chinese point-(wo)man in this election.

Photo by Lim Weixiang for Mothership.sg Photo by Lim Weixiang for Mothership.sg

According to The Straits Times, some analysts pointed out that Murali may be at a disadvantage as a minority candidate, "given that Bukit Batok has a higher proportion of Chinese residents than the national average — some of whom are elderly who may be more comfortable speaking in Mandarin."

This is where the bilingual MCCY Minister chipped in to help.

Speaking fluently in Mandarin, the popular Yuhua SMC MP was an effective wing-(wo)man in endorsing Murali as the "number one person" and the "best man" to be PAP's Bukit Batok SMC MP.

During the past week, Fu said her informal survey with residents and grassroots leaders revealed that Murali was a name that many of them highlighted and endorsed.

Even without Fu, Murali appeared quietly confident in winning over the Chinese-speaking residents in Bukit Batok.

Maybe it is because Murali was rumoured to have already bested a Chinese-speaking star candidate at Paya Lebar in Aljunied GRC last year.

Incidentally, Paya Lebar also has a higher proportion of Chinese residents than the national average, a fact Murali himself pointed out during the press conference.

Speaking about the Chinese-speaking star candidate...

A'>
BOY'S PRAYER. Good luck to Dr Chee. Good luck to Mr Murali. More important than either of them -- Best of luck to...

Posted by Chen Show Mao on Monday, March 21, 2016

It appears from this Facebook post to the Workers' Party MP's page that Chen does not agree with this statement, made six months ago by The Straits Times. He then urges Bukit Batok residents to support Chee so that he can have a re-match with Murali.

It seems that Chen has taken a position for WP, which is to openly support SDP so that he can personally contest against Murali again.

Someone please own up — did anyone take over Chen's FB account at 11pm on Monday?

 

4. Murali's candidacy poses its residents two options to choose from — a seasoned "political" politician or a seasoned "grassroots" politician.

CSJ and Murali Source: Chee Soon Juan Facebook / Photo by Lim Weixiang

The media asked Murali about competing against "a seasoned politician" like Chee, implying that there was a mismatch in terms of name recognition, political experience, and maybe the number of books written and political speeches given.

Afterall, this is The Chee Soon Juan.

Leader of the SDP for over two decades. Regular contributor to Wall Street Journal and the Huffington Post, 2003 winner of the "Defender of Democracy" award and the symbol of Hong Lim Park.

Okay, maybe we are comparing apples to oranges.

How about an apple to apple comparison? Chee has fought in four GE campaigns compared to Murali's one.

How about one's time in politics? Chee's 23 years vs Murali's 5 years (since GE 2011)

So Murali provided his soundbite of the day:

"Politics is really about serving residents. And I consider myself seasoned because I have put in quite a bit of time serving the residents' needs"

What Murali is not saying is this retort — 16 years in Bukit Batok vs Chee's less than 16 days there.

 

5. There is new milestone this BE — but no one has noticed it yet.

Photo by Lim Weixiang for Mothership.sg Photo by Lim Weixiang for Mothership.sg

On media queries about the timing of announcement of the new candidate, DPM Tharman said,

"We felt that a week was about the right time to let things settle and also listen to views. There's no reason to delay the announcement of a candidate that we feel very comfortable with. If we had some doubts about the candidate I think we may have held off for awhile — we had as I mentioned earlier in the week we had a few strong names to look at — and we decided in the course of the week that we were very comfortable with Murali as our choice."

And later on, when asked again, he added:

"The straight answer is we had intended to announce today. We wanted to give it at least a week for the reasons I mentioned, and we intended to announce our candidate today. It just so happened — he was away until yesterday as well — although he was always in touch with us. But basically we wanted to have a good week before we announced our candidate. I'm not surprised that Dr Chee has also announced his candidacy yesterday, but certainly nothing surprising."

We can tell you that the early PAP candidate announcement IS surprising.

In the last two BEs over the past four years, the PAP candidates are announced only after the writ of election is issued by the President.

Punggol East BE: On Jan 9 2013, President Tony Tan issued the writ of election for the electoral division of Punggol East.

On Jan 10, 2013 and Jan 14, 2013, PAP and WP unveiled their candidates Koh Poh Koon and Lee Li Lian respectively.

Hougang BE: On May 9 2012, President Tan issued the writ of election for the electoral division of Hougang.

One day later, PAP and WP unveiled their candidates Desmond Choo and Png Eng Huat respectively.

Was Chee a factor? Or was it mere coincidence that PAP wanted only a week to decide?

Whatever the case, unofficial campaigning seems to have begun (at least for the SDP in the markets last weekend and PAP's block visits yesterday).

Which then lead us to a question for the Elections Department.

According to the ELD on parliamentary elections,

"Candidates can start campaigning after the notice of contested election is issued, up to the start of the day before Polling Day (which is the Cooling-Off Day). Candidates may also be given air-time by the television stations".

So if we see Chee and Murali at the markets and blocks at Bukit Batok this weekend, are they breaking any rules?

 

Top photo by Lim Weixiang for Mothership.sg.

If you like what you read, follow us on Facebook and Twitter to get the latest updates.

If you like what you read, follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and Telegram to get the latest updates.