Health insurance CEO killer Luigi Mangione will not face death sentence, federal judge rules

A federal judge has ruled that Luigi Mangione will not face a possible death sentence for killing health insurance CEO Brian Thompson.

On Jan. 30, 2026, Manhattan U.S. District Court Judge Margaret Garnett ordered the dismissal of two of four criminal counts that Mangione faced in the case.

One of the counts would have exposed him to a potential death penalty if convicted, reported CNBC.

Garnett noted that the potential maximum sentence that the 27-year-old now faces for the remaining two counts under U.S. federal stalking laws is "life in prison without parole".

Thomson, 50, was fatally shot on Dec. 4, 2024, while he was going to attend an investors' conference organised by his parent company, UnitedHealth Group, in central New York.

Judge said analysis may appear 'tortured and strange'

Garnett tossed out a third count, which accused Mangione of the murder through firearm use during the alleged stalking.

This third count would have made Mangione eligible for a possible death sentence.

The fourth count, which was also dismissed, accused Mangione of using a firearm equipped with a silencer during the stalking.

The judge admitted that the analysis she applied to the dismissal argument may be seen as strange, reported CNN.

“The analysis contained in the balance of this Opinion may strike the average person – and indeed many lawyers and judges – as tortured and strange, and the result may seem contrary to our intuitions about the criminal law.”

She ruled that the Supreme Court precedent bound her to conclude that the first two criminal counts were not defined as "crimes of violence".

“But it represents the Court’s committed effort to faithfully apply the dictates of the Supreme Court to the charges in this case.”

A separate motion by Mangione's defence team to suppress the contents of the backpack he possessed during his arrest was dismissed.

This was the same backpack that he wore when he was questioned and detained by police after being arrested at a McDonald's outlet in Altoona, Pennsylvania, five days after the killing, was dismissed.

The backpack, which was searched by police, contained a loaded gun magazine, handgun, silencer and a red notebook among other items.

Mangione's attorneys have asserted that the search was not legally valid as no search warrant was obtained.

Mangione also faces murder charges in Manhattan's state court, where prosecutors are seeking to try him before the federal trial.

Cases lodged in New York state courts have no death penalty option.

Manhattan's District Attorney’s office is attempting to convince the state judge to set their trial for July, according to CNN.

However, the federal trial is scheduled to begin with jury selection on September 8, followed by opening statements on October 13, and Mangione’s legal team said they would need the time to prepare for it.

Related articles

Top photo from Luigi Archive/X and NYPD